Has anyone seen anything like this reported?

[VonVulcan]

Or is this just all \"made up\"?




----- Original Message -----
Sent: Sunday, November 04, 2007 9:21 AM
Subject: Report from USMC - Al Anbar Province, Iraq

Saturday, October 20, 2007 6:40 PM
Subject: Report from USMC - Al Anbar Province, Iraq


From: Dill, LtCol Jeffrey J (1/7 Bn Co)

Sent: Friday, October 05, 2007 3:45 PM
Classification: UNCLASSIFIED

Family, friends, and Fellow Marines,

As promised, here is my first 'update' from this tour in Iraq. I will try
and get one of these out about every month. I hope this finds you all doing
well. It has been a very fast moving month and a half as we moved the 1,000+
Marines from 1/7 and literally tons of equipment and material half way
around the world through Kuwait and eventually into Iraq. We have
inventoried and signed for well over a hundred pieces of rolling stock,
thousands of pieces of electronic equipment and computers, joined a few
hundred more reinforcements to 1/7 (making us now 'Task Force 1/7') and then
we put everyone in their new positions, spreading us out over 500 squar e
kilometers. Needless to say, the Marines of the First Team have been busy!

Here is the million dollar question I have been asked repeatedly since I
have arrived, 'How is it compared to the last time you were in Iraq?' Well,
I was in Hit, the main city within our AO, last October and daytime
operations were limited to tanks and BFVs driving around the outskirts of
the city because to venture inside meant a certain attack by an IED, RPG,
small arms, or all of the above. Recently, I went on a 3 hour dismounted
patrol through town in the middle of the afternoon and my biggest worry was
having enough candy for all the children that came up to me to say hello and
shake my hand.

I stopped in stores and talked to the merchants to see how business is
doing. They told me business is good and improving everyday. I even went to
a few shops to look for a carpet for my office and enjoyed myself as I tried
to get the price lowe red from 'rich' American prices to normal Iraqi prices.
I wasn't successful but will keep trying!

I stopped in one of the police stations in the city so I could make plans
with the Station Chief to remove a number of the cement barriers on the
street in order to open traffic back up. Those barriers were a must before
as there was a constant threat of a suicide vehicle ramming into the station
in an attempt to kill as many of the police officers as possible.

While that threat still exists, the security provided by the police and my
Marines has allowed us to take risks in certain areas as we try and balance
security needs and normalcy.

I spend many hours working with the numerous city counsels and Mayors in my
AO to address and solve many issues, problems, and to plan for the future. A
year ago, the city councils would not show up to work because if they did,
they were killed as they were seen as 'agents' of the Americans by AQI. Now,
they look forward to my arrival so issues like schools, rubble removal,
water treatment plants, sewage repairs, repairs of the electrical grids,
infrastructure modernization, and an assortment of other issues can be
worked out, prioritized, and assets allocated for them to begin work.

I also spend a great deal of time with the major Sheiks in my AO.

They are some of the most gracious hosts you have ever met. My Marines and I
are treated liked royalty every time we arrive. Delicious lamb, goat,
sheep, kabobs, fresh fruits and vegetables are served in amounts we could
never finish and we always eat first and get the seats of honor closest to
the Sheik. We then adjourn for Chi tea and discuss issues that require my
attention such as security, economic stimulation, tribal reconciliation,
local government issues, and of course stories of past battles and
fights...all embellished but they make great stories anyway .

Three brothers in the town of Baghdadi, one of whom who happens to be the
Police Chief and is known as the 'Lion of Al Anbar', are particularly
gracious hosts. They were some of the first to stand up against AQI and to
stand with the Marines. They have suffered greatly for choosing to fight AQI
and for freedom. The Police Chief, Colonel Shab'an has had no less then 7
direct assassination attempts against him. I was here last year and saw him
after one attack against him was nearly successful. One of his brothers was
killed, a brother-in-law was tortured and beheaded, and one of his younger
brothers lost his legs in a mortar attack. Yet, he remains committed to a
free and independent Iraq. His talks to me about freedom, democracy, and his
loyalty to Iraq and justice are inspiring.

Colonel Shab'an has become a sort of folk hero to his community and his
willingness to stand up for their freedom and safety has inspired thousan ds
of Iraqis. His two brothers, one a Sheik and the other a local businessman
are also servants to their community. The Sheik is the City Council Chairman
and has almost single handedly reorganized the local government from a board
of obstructionists to a functioning and effective governing body who work
almost non-stop to improve the lives of the people within their area.

The other brother is a very successful businessman who has donated tens of
thousands of dollars to fix water treatment plants, to pay of the salaries
of the police before the national government could or would, and his source
network has led to the successful capture of many terrorists and criminals.

The nights in their neighborhood are particularly enjoyable as we sit
outside to eat and the children in the neighborhood run around, laughing,
and sneaking up to listen to me talk or to try and get some more candy from
me. They are so proud of the security th ey have established for their
families, their tribe, and the people in their community. I am proud just to
be considered their friend.

Overall, the folks I have met are good people who want to raise their
families, farm their land, and just have the ability to choose their own
future for one of the few times in their country's history. Their admiration
and appreciation to us and to the American people for the opportunity we
have offered them is genuine and heartfelt.

While there has been a great deal of progress, there is still much to do.

While most of the terrorists have been forced from the population centers,
there are still secret cells. We have found and been attacked by a number of
IEDs already. We have found a good number of buried caches along the river
banks that were planted there for future use against us. Iraq is far from a
peaceful land; there are many political issues above my level that must be
worked out. The rifts between the religious sects are as tough a problem to
figure out as anything else ever has been...think Catholics and Protestants
in Northern Ireland.

The bottom line is this...we are winning the counter-insurgency fight here
in Al Anbar. We are winning as a result of the past 5 years of work by
thousands of Marines, Sailors, and Soldiers who worked tirelessly to get us
where we are today. This didn't happen overnight and we lost many good men
and women to achieve it. We have put the enemy on the run and we are not
letting the pressure off. We continue to hunt him down and provide him no
rest. My Marines, actually your Marines, are patrolling in the cities, in
the desert, and on the river to find the enemy and destroy him. And the
Marines do not patrol alone. Almost every operation we do has Iraqi Police,
Army, or both with the Marines. They are brave, committed to winning, and
they try as hard as they can to emulate the Marines they are serving with.
At the same time we continue to build our relationships with the local
leaders, Sheiks, and most importantly the Iraq people.

I am optimistic that if given the time and support of the American people,
we can help create a country whose vast natural resources and potential will
make it one of the strongest and most powerful nations in the region.

Iraq will be our Ally and they will not forget the sacrifices the American
people have made on their behalf. I realize and understand that many back
home are tired of this conflict and want it to end. I will not provide any
argument there but I will offer that 'wishing' away this problem is not
reality. The Islamic extremists that wish to destroy us are not going away,
they cannot be 'talked' to, and they will not negotiate.

I have been here three years in a row now and I can see the progress. I ca n
see the improvement in the capabili ties and potential in the Iraqi Security
Forces, I can see the willingness and desire of civic and local leaders to
build a better future for their people, and I can see that most of the
civilian population has turned its back on AQI because of their empty
promises. I can see hope, a hope that many Iraqis have never known before,
and a hope they do not want to loose.

Your Marines are doing exceptionally well. They are focused, they are
disciplined, and they continue to attack each day with vigor and enthusiasm.
I am continually inspired by their courage, dedication, and willingness to
sacrifice for others. I am truly blessed for the privilege to lead them.

I would like to thank all of you for your continued prayers and support. It
means the world to us to know you are all still behind us and that you want
us to successfully complete this mission. Please remember all the 1/7
families and all the families of those servin g here in Iraq that have been
left behind in your prayers as well.



Semper Fidelis and God Bless,

JJ

LtCol JJ Dill
Commanding Officer
Task Force 1/7
Hit, Iraq

[Testiculese]

Looks like propaganda.

[Grendel]

x2, esp. since it's planted all over the net w/o further references.

[Ferno]

usually if you get it through email from someone you don't know.. it's usually bs spam.

[Tunnelcat]

When the car bombs, IED's and shootings stop, I'll believe it then.

There's a saying I read some time ago. It stated that: \"a government is most likely to lie in a time of war\".

[TIGERassault]

Well, I didn't hear any such reports from reliable scources, so I wouldn't think so.

[Top Wop]

You could ask the people on this website if its legit or not:
http://www.sftt.org/cgi-bin/csNews/csne ... wone&id=47

[Lothar]

I can't vouch for the authenticity of that particular e-mail. Don't know if it's real, don't know where it came from. It could be fabricated.

But, the things it expresses are becoming common sentiments on milblogs and such. The latest troop surge, RoE revisions, and the Iraqi army/police clearing some major hurdles has made Iraq much safer overall. So it wouldn't surprise if the e-mail is legit.

[Ferno]

Lothar..

NOTHING through email via spam is legit. you know that. Just because it says something similar to what you read, doesn't make it true.

I mean what's next... people start believing they can get cheap viagra or lose 50 lbs in a week?

[VonVulcan]

It wasn't spam, it came to me directly from a retired military friend of mine who has
friends and family members currently serving in the military. Weather or not he knows
this particular letter writer or not, I don't know.
The reactions to it were interesting anyways.

[CDN_Merlin]

IMHO, if you don't know the person first hand who wrote this, it's spam. Friend of a friend of a friend of a friend is spam. I'm also getting tired of email jokes sent from my friends. I've told them not to email me them but they still do. Those and the stupid \"send this ti ten friends\" stuff.

[roid]

Lothar..

NOTHING through email via spam is legit. you know that. Just because it says something similar to what you read, doesn't make it true.

I mean what's next... people start believing they can get cheap viagra or lose 50 lbs in a week?

that Ron Paul spam seemed true, it was like a copy paste from his website/flyers or whatver.

[Lothar]

NOTHING through email via spam is legit.

Sometimes the crap you get in your inbox is actually true, just unsolicited. Some of it is actually forwarded true stories. I'm not willing to write something off just because I don't know its origins. Withhold judgment (either way!) until you're sure. We don't know if this e-mail is legit or not; pretending you DO know is stupid.

So, for VV, if you want to know about that specific e-mail, why not just ask back up the chain? Ask the guy who sent it to you where he got it from. Ask on the website TW posted. Contact an active-duty member of the guy's batallion (dig through this page; may be out of date.) You may even be able to contact him directly by un-munging the e-mail address on this page.

If you want to know if the ideas expressed are legit, read more milblogs. Most of what the guy expresses has become common sentiment -- the surge, changed RoE, and more competent Iraqi forces have made the country a much different place.

[Grendel]

Well, according to http://icasualties.org lists 854 so far (look for \"U.S. Casualties By Calendar Year\") -- highest ever since 2003. Looking at the deaths by week or month and the reasons tells a story tho.

Here's more background from the WP

The record death toll of at least 852 U.S. military personnel killed this year underscores the high cost of the American troop increase, launched in February, which has begun to drive down the sectarian violence that once gripped much of the country.

\"The strategy was to interject our soldiers between the Iraqi citizens and the terrorists, insurgents and militias,\" Lt. Col. Douglas A. Ollivant, chief of plans for American forces in Baghdad, said in an interview. \"A regrettable consequence of that is your casualties go up.\"

But the grim milestone belied a more optimistic trend: Troop fatalities have declined sharply since early summer. In October, the death toll for U.S. troops fell to 38, its lowest level since March 2006, according to icasualties.org, a Web site that tracks military fatalities more rapidly than the Pentagon makes its numbers public.

Lt. Col. Dale Kuehl, a battalion commander in western Baghdad, said fighting in the spring had helped secure local neighborhoods. He said there had not been a roadside bomb attack in his area of operations for three months and no mortar or rocket attacks since July.