Supreme Court: Death Penalty for Minors Unconstitutional

For discussion of life's issues: current events, social trends and personal opinions.

Moderators: Tunnelcat, Jeff250

Is the Supreme Court correct to hold that murderers under the age of 18 years old should not be eligible for the death penalty?

Yes, persons younger than 18 years old are always less mature than adults, and to try and execute them as adults would be cruel and unusual punishment.
13
33%
No, states should be permitted to exercise discretion on a case-by-case basis.
26
65%
I don't think this is an important decision, one way or the other.
1
3%
 
Total votes: 40
User avatar
woodchip
DBB Benefactor
DBB Benefactor
Posts: 17865
Joined: Tue Jul 06, 1999 2:01 am

Post by woodchip »

Since the threads course has tasked off course a bit, let me add something to the death penalty business. Most of us here are naturally concerned that a innocent man is not put to death in error. Since executions have put the wrong person to death, instead of the endless appeal process, let us look at the prosecutors and law enforcement agencies handling the case.
If a condemned man is later found to be innocent, he is given a new suit and fifty bucks and shown the sunlight. In most cases the individual has no recourse for damages for time spent incarcerated or loss of his good name. Perhaps we should start looking at repercussions to the overzealous prosecutor who wanted a quick settling of a murder to show how "effective" he is or the police who have been known to "doctor" evidence so it looks like they are doing their job by getting a murderer off the streets. Knowing you may be sued over a inept job always makes one look harder at the job at hand. While I know someone will say this may put a unfair burden on the police and prosecutors office I say so what. Don't go into a line of work that you are not prepared to do due diligence.
User avatar
woodchip
DBB Benefactor
DBB Benefactor
Posts: 17865
Joined: Tue Jul 06, 1999 2:01 am

Post by woodchip »

Since the Judges brought up international law, here is a example of how the Brits handle youthful miscreants:

A 12-year-old boy has been detained for life by a judge at Teesside Crown Court for raping his teacher at a special needs centre.

http://www.sky.com/skynews/article/0,,3 ... 10,00.html
Post Reply