Wow, that test was pretty wacky. At least morally speaking, I consider myself conservative-bordering-on-fanatic, and that test rated me dead center. Maybe because I said "no" to all the racism questions? Really weird if you ask me.
I agree with Goob about the first quiz--I felt a lot of those questions were complex questions. I needed "no opinion", "neither", "both equally", and "what the heck are you asking?" buttons. I also felt it was warped in another way--no sensetivity to nuance. It asked me two or three questions about racism, but they seemed entirely designed to test whether or not I was a racist--which is a "right wing wacko" vs. "the rest of the world" distinction. And then it neglected to measure such things as how I felt about how racial reconciliation ought to be accomplished, which is a fairer right/left breakdown question. If they put the center just to the left of "right wing wacko," small wonder I ended up in the center--I'm barely two hairs left of right wing wacko.
The right/left breakdown as I see it is based on a series of issues, and it's hard to find a common thread that runs through them. Some of the themes on the left are large government and individual freedom with respect to expression and privacy, while some on the right are traditional moral values and individual freedom with respect to property. I've also perceived the left to lean more towards entitlement--the government should take care of you--and the right to lean more towards personal responsibility--you should take care of yourself. But those are just themes, and certainly not every issue breaks down where you'd expect it to.
As a result, most people don't find that they're purebred right or left, but "tend to side with the left most of the time" and so forth. A quiz doesn't really measure that, and just gives you a single rating.
Another problem with a quiz is that if you're a right wing nut half the time and a left wing nut the other half the time, you end up looking like a centerist, rather than the apolitical nut you are.
Probably a better way to get a feel for it than a quiz is to look at a variety of issues, and see which side you end up agreeing with a lot--and more importantly, why.
Here are some illuminating questions, as I see things. Bear in mind that my analysis is probably as biased as anyone's, both in the questions I ask, and in my analysis of those questions. That is, though I consider myself a fair-minded person and I strive to write honestly, bear in mind that this quiz *is* written by someone who describes herself with such phrases as "two hairs left of a right wing nut"...
(1) How do you feel about the death penalty?
The left feels you shouldn't have it, and the right feels that you should. The more you feel you should *never* have it under *any* circumstance, the farther you are toward the left; the more you feel that it should be frequent and easy, the farther you are toward the right. A centerist would probably feel that it was justified in a small number of cases, and should be heavily controlled and regulated.
(2) How do you feel about the relationship between the races--and in particular, how do you feel about affirmative action?
In a nutshell, the left feels that affirmative action is helping the race situation, and the right feels that it's hurting it. The more you feel that racism is rampant, and that laws need to be passed to keep whites from oppressing others, the farther you are to the left. The more you feel that racism is basically a solved problem, and that any economic disparities will take care of themselves, the farther you are to the right. You enter right wing wacko country when you begin to say, "You know, maybe the racists are right..."
It seems to me (and I may be wrong) that the left on this issue thinks that if we can remedy the economic differences between races (i.e., blacks tending to be lower income), then the social problems (racial tension, lingering racism) will take care of themselves. The right, on the other hand, thinks that we need to remedy the social problems--get people of different races to treat each other kindly or even to ignore race in their interactions--and the economic problems will then take care of themselves. (Fellow DBB'ers of all wings check me here--is that a good synopsis of the situation?)
(3) How do you feel about homosexuality? How do you feel about homosexual marriage?
The left feels that homosexuality is noble, and the right feels that it's degrading. The more you feel that homosexuality is a good thing, or that it's equal to heterosexuality, the farther you are to the left; the more you feel that it's a bad thing, and inferior to heterosexuality, the farther you are to the right.
Likewise, the left feels that homosexual marriage is a good thing, a right due homosexuals. The right feels that homosexual marriage is a bad thing, an assault on traditional marriage. It's hard to draw up a very centerist stance on this issue, but promoting civil unions for gays instead of marriage is a center-left idea, and permitting homosexuality while allowing homosexual relationships no governmental recognition is a center-right idea.
(4) How do you feel about the relationship between religion and government?
The left feels that religion and government ought to have nothing to do with each other, and the right doesn't mind them associating a bit. The left comes down against things like prayer in schools, or judges displaying monuments of the ten commandments; the right comes down allowing faith-based laws. Really, it comes down to the first amendment's two balancing clauses, that the government should not establish a religion, and that it should not inhibit religious expression. The more heavily you weigh the first clause, the farther you are to the left. (Do you feel it means the government shouldn't give funding to a particular church, or do you go so far as to say it means public officals should have no religious affiliation whatsoever?) On the other hand, the more heavily you weight the second phrase, the farther you are to the right. (Do you think leaders of state sponsored institutions ought to be able to lead public prayer? Do you go so far as to say lawmakers ought to be able to make laws based on their religious views?) Quite frankly, I don't even *know* where center is on this issue, because I'm so far to the right. Somebody else point it out, please.
(5) How do you feel about abortion?
The left feels that abortions are okay, and the right feels that they aren't. The more you feel that abortions ought to be accessible, common, allowed late term, etc., the farther you are to the left. The more you feel abortions ought to be illegal even early term or in situations like a pregnancy resulting from rape, the farther you are to the right. The left values the rights of the woman higher, while the right values the life of the unborn higher. If one completely overwhelms the other for you, then you are far to that side. A good example of a centerish position was Clinton's "safe, legal and rare" stance.
(6) How do you feel about gun control?
The more you feel that guns should be regulated or even removed from the population, the farther you are to the left. The more you feel that guns should be available (in potentially very large sizes!), the farther you are to the right. The main values here seem to be public safety versus personal liberty.
(7) How do you feel about how much the government should tax you?
The left feels that taxes ought to be high, and the government ought to provide lots of services. The right feels that taxes ought to be low, and private individuals and corporations ought to provide lots of services. Left wacko country starts when you endorse socialism.
( 8 ) How do you feel about who the government should tax?
The left feels that the government should tax the rich lots, lots more than the poor, and the right feels that the government should tax the rich quite a bit more than the poor. This is kind of a funny issue due to the similarity there, but the right question to ask is, do you think the rich are bearing an appropriate tax burden? If you feel they're paying too little, you're on the left; if you feel they're paying too much, you're on the right. (As it stands, the rich pay quite a lot more than the poor...) If you want to tax the rich so much and give the poor so much that the society becomes effectively communist, then you're *way* to the left.
(9) How do you feel about drug laws?
The left feels that a lot of drugs ought to be legal, while the right thinks they ought to be illegal. The more serious drugs you think ought to be legal, and and the more you think should be available for recreational (as opposed to medicinal) purposes, the farther to the left you are. Marijuana seems to be about where the line is drawn. Bizarrely, though (and I do not understand this), the sides seem to reverse when it comes to tobacco--it's voices on the *left* I hear wanting to make the companies liable for cancer and such, and voices on the *right* celebrating the liberty to mess up your health if you want to. Somebody who has a better understanding of the logic here might want to explain a little better, so in the mean time suffice it to say that the drug issue's complex.
There are probably more and better questions to ask. I understand welfare is an issue that breaks down right/left, but I don't understand it well enough to even be able to ask the right question, let alone give a fair analysis of the situation. And there are probably others I've forgotten--I tend to leave out economic considerations because I don't understand them or don't care about them. Feel free to comment on anything I've missed. But that's a start from my perspective, and certainly essay answers allow for a more nuanced understanding of the view.
My scores--
Death penalty: Two hairs short of right wing wacko. I'd like to see a lot more of the death penalty, a lot more consistently than we have it.
Race: Solid righty. I value social reconciliation, and think that evening up economoic statistics is pointless. But I acknowledge that racism still exists and is bad.
Homosexuality: Right wing wacko. I think homosexuality
itself is wrong, and wouldn't mind laws that said so. But I'm also content understanding that society doesn't agree with me, and I like living in a society that allows sexual freedom in privacy. Oddly enough, I really like the idea of civil unions for homosexuals, which is a leftish position, but I take it for rightish reasons--that I want to protect marriage in name, but propogate it in spirit: I want to have some social institution that keeps non-traditional families together, while still recognizing that they're non-traditional families.
Religion & government: Right wing nut, definitely. Not only do I like faith based initiatives, I think they're the only sensible way to run a government.
Abortion: Far righty. I'll admit abortion when the life of the mother's in jeapoardy, and that's about it.
Gun control: Centerish, leaning probably a bit left. I don't think I'd really mind an unarmed population, and the public safety idea has merit. But I also think people ought to have access at least to guns for various self-defense and recreational reasons. I do think the second amendment idea of a militia to keep the government in check is just a *tad* dated...
Taxes (amount): Slight righty. I don't really care, but I trust the people more than the government doing most things.
Taxes (who): Neutral. I don't feel I know enough to be able to make a fair judgement on the issue.
Drugs: Solid righty. I like the drug laws the way they are, for the most part. Keep the ones that can really mess you up illegal.
Overall, I tend to lean pretty far to the right. Really, I kind of like being a wacko--it means I *really* believe the things I believe